November 6, 2026

We Should Not Need a Courtroom: Part Four

We Should Not Need a Courtroom: Part Four

This is Part Four of a four-part essay. Start with Part One.

Part Four: We Still Do Not Know Enough

The country had a version of this conversation in 2002, during the Andrea Yates trial. A Texas jury convicted her. An appeals court later overturned the conviction, and in 2006 a second jury, hearing the same case, found her not guilty by reason of insanity. More than twenty years later, the research has not moved nearly as far as the outrage has.

Postpartum psychosis still does not have its own diagnosis in the DSM. The closest the manual comes is a specifier, with peripartum onset, attached to another mood or psychotic disorder, and the experts who study this illness say even that describes its timing inaccurately.

In October 2025, an international group of those experts published a consensus statement in Biological Psychiatry arguing that postpartum psychosis should be classified as a distinct condition within the bipolar disorders, with its own timing and criteria. Their reasons were concrete. Most women who have it show prominent mood symptoms. It responds very well to lithium and to electroconvulsive therapy, the same treatments used for severe bipolar illness. About half of women with a first episode go on to develop bipolar disorder. The panel's argument was practical: an illness without its own classification is easier to miss and slower to treat, and that delay has cost lives.

What is striking is how much is already known, and how little of it reaches the women who need it.

We know the window. The risk is concentrated in the first weeks after birth to a degree few illnesses in psychiatry can match. We know who is at highest risk: women with bipolar disorder, and women who have already had an episode. A woman who has had postpartum psychosis once faces roughly a one in three chance of it returning after a later birth.

We also know that in many cases it can be prevented. In a Dutch study published in 2012, women with a history of postpartum psychosis alone who started lithium immediately after delivery did not relapse. Among those who declined it, more than four in ten did. The study was small and needs to be repeated. What it shows is that the risk can be identified during pregnancy, before the baby arrives, if someone asks the right questions.

Asking the right questions is where the system breaks down.

Most postpartum screening is built for depression. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that pediatricians screen mothers for postpartum depression at the one, two, four, and six month well-baby visits, which makes sense, since a new mother sees her baby's doctor far more often than her own. Those screening tools are designed to find depression. They are not designed to catch the early signs of mania or psychosis, and psychosis usually arrives before the first of those visits.

When a woman does need a hospital, the options in this country are thin. Postpartum Support International's directory lists five inpatient perinatal psychiatric units in the United States. None of them admits the baby to stay overnight with the mother. England, France, and Australia have had mother and baby units for decades, where mother and infant are admitted together. Most American women who need inpatient psychiatric care after a birth are admitted to a general psychiatric unit, away from an infant they may still be trying to nurse.

More research is needed, and it is needed for reasons that go beyond any single case. While the public was focused on the rarest outcome there is, the more common danger got almost no attention. In data from maternal mortality review committees in thirty-six states, compiled by the CDC for 2017 through 2019, mental health conditions, including suicide and overdose, were the leading underlying cause of pregnancy-related death, at nearly a quarter. The committees judged more than four in five pregnancy-related deaths overall to be preventable. In an earlier CDC analysis, nearly two thirds of the mental health deaths happened between six weeks and a year after delivery, long after most women have had their last postpartum appointment.

That is where women are actually dying, and it is largely preventable.

Fear-based messaging makes this worse. If the only thing a new mother hears about postpartum illness is danger, she is less likely to tell anyone when something feels wrong, because she is afraid of what will happen if she does. What helps is women and families knowing the signs, and knowing that these conditions respond to treatment.

The most useful thing anyone can do with all of this is ask the new mothers in your life how they are really doing, and ask the people around them what has changed, because family often sees what a short appointment cannot. And if what you hear worries you, help her get to someone who specializes in this.

I say that as a woman who went through postpartum depression three times, and as a psychologist who would send her to that specialist rather than treat her myself.

For free, confidential support during or after pregnancy, call or text the National Maternal Mental Health Hotline at 1-833-852-6262. Call or text 988 during a mental health crisis. If someone is in immediate danger or appears to be experiencing postpartum psychosis, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department.