October 26, 2026

We Should Not Need a Courtroom: Part One

We Should Not Need a Courtroom: Part One

Part One: Three Times

I had postpartum depression three times.

The first time, I did not know that was what it was. I had just had a baby, and every part of my life had changed. Before her, I had been hyper independent. I worked. I loved my work. I could decide what to do with my time and where to go. Then there was a newborn who needed me to feed her, hold her, and keep her alive. I was no longer independent of another person’s needs, even for a few hours.

I assumed the disconnection and flatness were part of adjusting to motherhood. I saw other women who were pregnant or holding their babies, and they seemed happy in a way I was not. I thought something was wrong with me. I connected it to my trauma history and treated my inability to feel what I believed a mother should feel as evidence of some defect in me.

I did not understand that depression could interfere with the feeling of connection itself. I loved my baby, but I could not always feel the emotional attachment I believed was supposed to arrive with her.

The second time, I knew it was postpartum depression.

My daughters were nineteen months apart. There were now two babies, and for several months, I felt resentful that the second one had made my life harder. She had not done anything wrong, of course. She was a quiet, easy baby who was deeply attached to me. But depression has a way of attaching the burden to the person who needs you most.

Because I recognized it the second time, I gave myself space to adjust. I believed my body was recovering from the hormones, physical trauma, and exhaustion of giving birth. In my mind, if it took nine months to have a baby, it could reasonably take nine months to recover from having one. I did not expect myself to return immediately to who I had been before.

I remember when something changed.

She was about five months old. Someone reached to take her from me, and she grabbed my shirt and buried her face in my shoulder. In that moment, I felt an overwhelming rush of love for her. It was not that I had begun loving her at five months old. The love had been there. I simply had not been able to feel it in that way. It had seemed chemically blocked, and then, suddenly, it was available to me.

The third time was worse.

It lasted somewhere between seven and nine months. I felt flat, overwhelmed, and sad. I also felt ashamed that something appeared to be wrong with me because I had not experienced the immediate emotional attachment to my babies that mothers are expected to describe.

I loved them. I cared for them. I kept going. But love as a commitment and love as an accessible feeling were not always the same experience.

When people suggested medication, I initially felt resentful. I heard the recommendation as confirmation that I was failing at motherhood. My memory is that I eventually did take medication because the depression lasted so long. What remains clearest is not the medication itself. It is how difficult it was to separate needing help from the belief that needing help meant I was not doing my job as a mother.

My experiences do not establish what another woman should do. They are not an argument for waiting, refusing medication, or assuming that postpartum symptoms will resolve on their own. They are simply what happened to me.

They also shaped my compassion for women who experience perinatal mental illness. Some women experience postpartum depression once and never again. Some have a different experience after each birth. Mine became progressively worse.

I am a psychologist, but I do not specialize in treating perinatal mood and anxiety disorders. If a woman came to my office a few weeks after giving birth in significant distress, I would refer her to someone with specific training in this area. Having lived through postpartum depression does not make me qualified to treat it. Personal experience and clinical expertise are not interchangeable.

My experience with depression also tells me very little about postpartum anxiety, postpartum OCD, or postpartum psychosis. Postpartum psychosis is not simply a more severe version of postpartum depression. It is a different illness that requires specialized assessment and treatment.

What my experience does help me understand is how quickly a woman can interpret her suffering as a moral failure.

We have created a remarkably narrow story about motherhood. A woman is expected to want a baby, enjoy being pregnant, feel transformed by childbirth, and experience immediate, uncomplicated love when the baby is placed in her arms.

That was not my experience.

I had not wanted to become a mother. When I became pregnant, I decided to become one, but I was not excited. I was terrified. I eventually became a very good mother, which was not something I initially believed I would be able to do. But becoming a good mother did not make pregnancy, childbirth, or caring for babies beautiful or easy.

My pregnancies were physically difficult. I gained a great deal of weight. My babies were large, between eight and nine pounds, and I went beyond my due date with two of them. Childbirth was physically and emotionally stressful. Motherhood changed my relationship with my body, my work, my independence, my finances, and my understanding of myself.

The first two times, I did not have a supportive husband or father beside me in the way I needed. He simply was not there. The father of my third child was supportive of her, but I do not know that he was particularly supportive of me. Supporting a baby is not always the same as supporting the woman who gave birth to one.

You can want to be a mother and hate having babies. You can love your children and grieve the life you had before them. You can care for a baby responsibly while feeling detached, resentful, frightened, or overwhelmed. None of those experiences fit comfortably inside the version of motherhood we prefer to discuss.

This summer, a trial involving a mother and postpartum psychosis became something much of the country watched and debated. I will not offer a clinical opinion about the woman at the center of it. I never evaluated her, and offering a diagnosis or forensic conclusion about someone you have never met violates an important boundary in my profession.

What disturbed me was the certainty with which so many other people did exactly that.

People formed conclusions about her illness, her intentions, her motherhood, and her character from pieces of a story. They spoke as though a woman’s behavior at the most catastrophic point of an illness explained everything about who she had been before it.

I do not know her full story. Most of the people commenting on it do not know it either. That should have made us more careful. Instead, it often made us more certain.

My three experiences with postpartum depression do not give me the authority to explain postpartum psychosis. They do, however, leave me with a lasting memory of how easily suffering can become evidence against a mother. We ask whether she loved her children before we ask what happened to her. We judge her response before we understand the illness. We expect motherhood to override biology, trauma, sleep deprivation, isolation, physical recovery, and the loss of a former life.

When it does not, we decide something is wrong with the woman.

Sometimes something is wrong. But illness is not the same as moral failure, and understanding that distinction should be where the conversation begins.

If you or someone you know is struggling after a birth, call or text the National Maternal Mental Health Hotline at 1-833-852-6262. Call or text 988 during a mental health crisis.